>> MIM Speaks
SURVIVING A GLOBAL DEFLATION
MARCH 28, 1999 -
THE STAR
PRIME Minister Datuk Seri Dr Mahathir Mohamad's call to
Malaysians to be prepared for a worldwide deflation and to
find ways for Malaysia to insure itself against it is timely
advice.
Our Prime Minister attributes the general meltdown of the
worldwide economy to the activities of the currency traders
and stock market-raiders, which have wiped out high growth and
wealth creation of several vibrant economies.
The occurrence of a global meltdown is a strong possibility as
some parts of the global economy are already showing signs
that could dampen growth.
The American economy, according to Federal Reserve chairman
Alan Greenspan, "continues to perform in an outstanding
manner" using "ample flow of capital to business and
households."
Greenspan further added that "sometimes moderation in economic
growth, however, might be required to sustain expansion".
The US economy expanded at a 3.7% annual rate in the third
quarter of 1998 and economic analysts predict growth to
continue through the first half of 1999 at a rate of at least
one to two per cent.
However, this growth will be subject to the vagaries of the
economies of other major trading partners of the United States
namely Latin America, China, Japan and Asia.
The Dow Jones index, enjoying a historical high, may be
plagued by contagion effects that may spill over froth Latin
America and Asia.
Any substantial decline in the Dow Jones would trigger an
outflow of hedge funds and capital flow. In such an uneventful
Dow Jones meltdown, mutual funds, pension funds and social
security funds with trillions of dollars will be wiped out.
But what is most important is that while the US economy is in
a period of robust growth, nothing has changed fundamentally.
Its long-run growth rate has not accelerated, productivity has
not risen and the structural unemployment rate has fallen by
one percentage point.
Come the next recession, Greenspan's triumphalism will seem
silly.
From the United States, let us look at Japan's financial mess.
Japan's economic sluggishness is souring life at home and
setting off alarm abroad.
Scandal after scandal has revealed shocking abuses: unethical
banking practices, illegal deals between financial
institutions and politicians, and strong-arm tactics of
organised crime.
Moreover, Japan's financial sector is swamped by a
mind-boggling array of bond debts and underfunded pension
liabilities amounting to US$1.5tril.
Tokyo promises economic stimulus and deregulation, but the
results are disappointing. Resolving Japan's banking crisis
and moderating the strength of the yen will be fundamental to
pulling the economy out of its worst post-war recession and
bringing respite to the global economy.
The Brazilian financial crisis increases the possibility that
the country and the Latin American region will plunge into
recession and add to the global gloom this year.
The Brazilian real has fallen almost 30% to the US dollar,
leading to capital flight with the foreign reserve declining
to US$42.6bil in October 1998.
With an external debt of US$228bil as at June 1998, the
capital flight is aggravating the debt repayment commitments.
If the Brazilian crisis gets worse, it is likely to adversely
affect the US stock market.
Under the current scenario of an economic meltdown coupled
with panic-stricken markets, we might see Europe and the
United States joining the rest of the world in a spiral of
falling output, inflationary pressures, rising structural
unemployment and social problems.
Under conditions of imminent global deflation, how can our
economy survive the crisis?
In September 1998, Malaysia imposed controls on capital flows
to unhook Malaysia from the world economy and currency
speculators.
The exchange control has provided relief and shown indications
of an economic recovery.
Substantial sums of monies parked overseas have returned home
and, subsequently, interest rates have fallen. The increase of
the stock market capitalisation by RM220bil in five months and
a trade surplus of RM99.4bil last December are positive signs.
However, against this backdrop of a positive scenario, the
Malaysian industrial production index fell sharply by 11.5% in
November, Malaysian GDP contracted 8.6% in the third quarter,
and applications to set up new manufacturing projects have
declined almost 50%.
The Government must address the issue of foreign investor
confidence and show a clearer commitment to reform.
It is inevitable the Government needs to encourage better
disclosure, corporate governance and legal framework on which
to build a sound functioning banking and credit environment.
The pillars of restructuring framework, including Danaharta
and Danamodal, represent a solid foundation in undertaking
reforms. The manner in which these instruments conduct their
recapitalisation asset purchase and debt restructuring is
critical and must be in conformity with the best management
practices.
The cardinal principle in the restructuring procedures is
emphasis on stronger prudential guidelines, intensified
supervision of financial institutions and financial
disclosure.
However, there appears to be relaxation of prudential
standards and disclosure requirements.
There is delay in the revelation of massive losses by certain
banks, and information on the utilisation of proceeds of
rights issues of certain public listed companies is not
forthcoming.
These policy reversals have sent wrong signals to markets and
fuelled investors' perceptions or policy unpredictability a
strong deterrent against foreign and domestic capital in all
forms.
Finally, the Government's principal goals of averting further
economic stress and achieving a rapid recovery are
appropriate.
As a prerequisite for sustainable long-term growth, highest
priority must be accorded to structural reforms and the
implementation of a comprehensive financial reform plan,
incorporating Stock Exchange listing criteria for foreign and
local firms, creating a civil right of action for insider
trading, comprehensive securities regulation, maintaining
market surveillance of trading, improving protective
mechanisms of minority shareholders through transparency and
disclosure requirements and enforcement of commercial fraud
offences.
|